How to avoid Social Security scams 

How to avoid Social Security scams 
Social security scams are a common practice of fraudsters. Here’s how you can help your clients detect and avoid them
AUG 15, 2024

The information age has brought with it many advantages and conveniences that you or your clients never would have imagined even a decade ago. But unfortunately, these perks are accompanied by many negative aspects as well.  

One of the worst things to come out of the internet and mobile phone technology are scams. There are many types of scams, but today InvestmentNews will focus on scams that make use of the Social Security Administration – your client’s benefits, in particular.  

Clients who are on Social Security or will get their Social Security benefits soon can fall for these types of scams, so it’s important for you to be informed. This way, you can help them avoid getting scammed in turn. Scammers often target senior citizens due to their unfamiliarity with technology.  

If you have any clients that are retirees, they can get duped and have their Social Security benefits or savings siphoned off by these despicable criminals. In this article, we shed light on common Social Security benefits frauds or scams so you can stay vigilant and help your clients avoid falling prey to these scams.  

How Social Security scams work 

What is a Social Security scam? According to the Social Security Administration, this is a fraudulent activity used by criminals to get sensitive information or money from those who are receiving Social Security or other benefits from the SSA. The perpetrators often use phone calls, emails, or text messages to impersonate SSA personnel and trick those on social security to give up their money or sensitive information.  

Scammers usually threaten their victims with the loss of their benefits in exchange for money or sensitive personal information.  

Why scammers want your clients’ information 

While it’s logical for these scammers to demand money, why would they ask for a retiree for their sensitive information? It can be at least one of two reasons:  

  • use the information to access bank accounts, debit cards, or other depository of SSA benefits 
  • sell their information to other bad actors on the Dark Web 

If the internet was a city, the Dark Web would be its dank, dark alley where illegal activities and contraband thrive. Some say that the Dark Web is not solely for illicit purposes, but this is contestable.   

One of the most popular illicit commodities on the Dark Web is sensitive personal information.  

Credit card numbers, email addresses, phone numbers, medical records, Social Security numbers – anything hackers can steal and have stolen via the internet. Data like this is often sold in bulk to scam artists who attempt all manner of deception to steal money and other valuables from those unfamiliar with their scams.  

Common types of Social Security scams 

When it comes to your clients’ social security benefits, there is a range of scams that bad actors use to target them. Here are the most common:  

1. The replacement Social Security card scam 

In this scenario, scammers target those who seek to replace their old social security cards. Scammers pose as SSA personnel and offer to replace the card with an expedited process for a fee. Once the victim pays, the scammers keep the “renewal fee” and disappear.  

How to avoid this scam: 

  • deal only with the SSA website or local SSA office to get a replacement card 
  • remember that getting a replacement Social Security card is FREE 
  • never transact with any online service that charges a fee for the replacement card 

2. The ‘threat of Social Security benefits suspension’ scam 

Fraudsters may approach individuals via email, text messages, or phone calls, claiming to be an SSA employee. They will claim that benefits will be suspended due to a problem with the account or suspicious activity connected to the account. The scammer will then offer to fix the problem and help the victim avoid a suspension of their benefits if they pay a certain amount.  

How to avoid this scam:  

  • don't panic or give in to the demands of the supposed SSA personnel 
  • remember that SSA personnel will NEVER personally contact them 
  • verify any irregularities or problems by contacting the SSA  

3. The SSA personnel impersonation scam 

Your client may receive a phone call, text messages, email, or be approached personally by someone who claims to be with the SSA. They may say that they found irregularities with your client’s account or with their Social Security benefits. In some cases, they might use scare tactics to pressure your client into giving them sensitive information like their bank account number or Social Security number. 

How to avoid this scam: 

  • don't share any personal information like phone number, social security number, etc.  
  • transact only with verified SSA personnel by going to the SSA website or local SSA offices 
  • call the local SSA office or check the SSA website 
  • hang up on suspicious individuals 

4. The 'Social Security investment opportunity' scam 

Your client may likewise receive a phone call, text message, email, or be approached in person by someone claiming to work for the SSA.  

Instead of asking your client for any information or money, they’ll make some outrageous claim that the government is releasing great investment opportunities. They may tell your client that these can supplement the social security benefits from their deceased spouse or any other Social Security benefits.  

The catch is that they’ll have to pay some money up front for the investment. Or maybe the investment sounds too good to be true.  

How to avoid this scam:  

  • if any “investment” exists, do research on it first 
  • don't believe any investment that claims to add to Social Security benefits 
  • no SSA investment would require sharing sensitive information 

5. The 'overpaid' Social Security scam 

Fraudsters may contact your client and inform them that they were “overpaid” in their last Social Security deposit or check. They will then say that your client will have to return the excess amount.  

Instead of asking for a cash deposit, they will ask for the excess amount in the form of wire transfers, gift cards, or other payment method that will be impossible to track. They may also threaten legal action if this refund is not made immediately.  

Here’s a video from the SSA that shows how these cunning people prey on retirees. Have your client watch the video and answer their questions.  

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yPY-HFXZS24

Here’s a closer look at Social Security benefits and how they work.  

How to avoid this scam:  

  • verify the overpayment directly at a local SSA office or via their customer service number 
  • check Social Security benefits account to verify any excess amount 
  • be wary of any request for immediate repayment  

Other measures to protect against Social Security scams 

Most scams are avoided simply by ignoring the fraudsters. If there are any problems or irregularities with Social Security benefits or accounts, keep in mind that:  

  • the SSA typically releases official announcements via reputable news outlets, their website or official emails 
  • it is NOT standard practice for SSA or government employees to personally contact anyone; SSA employees will only respond to queries if your client contacts them first 
  • most ordinary services of the SSA are free of charge, including taking claims for different Social Security benefits, whether it’s retirement, survivors, disability or lump sum death payment 
  • the SSA does not issue or offer any supplemental investments for bolstering Social Security payments. 

Perhaps the only instance where SSA staff will inform your client of a Social Security feature is when they first sign up to receive their benefits. They may speak to your client about the Social Security lump sum, an amount retroactively paid to retirees who filed for their benefits after reaching full retirement age.  

Before your client considers taking this lump sum, share this guide on the Social Security lump sum benefit

Your clients can avoid scams like this by checking the SSA website and looking up information on scams from time to time. The SSA usually posts a scam alert or public advisory warning of these scams.  

What to do if your client falls for a Social Security scam 

Let's say your client wasn’t aware of these fraudsters’ tactics and fell for one of these scams. How do you report a Social Security scam?  

First, report the incident to the Office of the Inspector General. The SSA has zero tolerance for fraudsters and actively investigates each scamming case.  

You or your client should submit a report online to the OIG website or report directly to the OIG's fraud hotline at 1-800-269-0271. The OIG will review your allegation and take appropriate action. 

Other measures your client can take include:  

  1. changing all their passwords to the web portals to online bank accounts. 
  1. not opening any suspicious emails. If your client provided the fraudsters with their phone numbers or emails, they could get flooded with spam. These could be more phishing attempts to get sensitive information like bank account details. 
  1. not accepting calls from unknown numbers 
  1. not giving out their personal details to just anyone 
  1. contacting their bank and credit card companies to notify them of the incident 
  1. checking their bank or credit cards for any unauthorized transactions 
  1. turning on security features like two-factor authentication for their banking, mobile wallet, and credit card apps on their phones 
  1. educating themselves - a Google search for “social security benefits scams” can turn up a lot of helpful information  

Your clients who are retired or on the brink of retirement are among the most vulnerable. Fraudsters see them as easy targets due to their lack of technological knowledge and regular income. The knowledge gap that retirees have about their Social Security benefits are common issues that scammers like to exploit.  

Even if you don’t have a fiduciary duty toward your clients, it’s your moral duty to inform them about scams like this to help protect them and their assets. Remember that some of your senior clients are heavily dependent on their Social Security benefits for their needs and may also rely on and must make the most out of HSA and Medicare. Losing even a few hundred dollars can be harmful to their well-being. 

While advances in fintech and other related technologies make finance an exciting and lucrative career, advisors and their clients should stay wary of the risks. Get all your fintech advice and updates here on InvestmentNews. 

Latest News

The power of cultivating personal connections
The power of cultivating personal connections

Relationships are key to our business but advisors are often slow to engage in specific activities designed to foster them.

A variety of succession options
A variety of succession options

Whichever path you go down, act now while you're still in control.

'I’ll never recommend bitcoin,' advisor insists
'I’ll never recommend bitcoin,' advisor insists

Pro-bitcoin professionals, however, say the cryptocurrency has ushered in change.

LPL raises target for advisors’ bonuses for first time in a decade
LPL raises target for advisors’ bonuses for first time in a decade

“LPL has evolved significantly over the last decade and still wants to scale up,” says one industry executive.

What do older Americans have to say about long-term care?
What do older Americans have to say about long-term care?

Survey findings from the Nationwide Retirement Institute offers pearls of planning wisdom from 60- to 65-year-olds, as well as insights into concerns.

SPONSORED The future of prospecting: Say goodbye to cold calls and hello to smart connections

Streamline your outreach with Aidentified's AI-driven solutions

SPONSORED A bumpy start to autumn but more positives ahead

This season’s market volatility: Positioning for rate relief, income growth and the AI rebound