How to restart Social Security benefits 

How to restart Social Security benefits 
Those who took their Social Security early can suspend and restart their benefits. Find out how to restart suspended Social Security benefits in this article
AUG 29, 2024

For many retirees or senior citizens, it’s a little-known fact that they have the option of suspending and restarting their benefits from the Old Age, Survivors and Disability Insurance (OASDI) aka Social Security.  

In certain situations, this can provide a lot of relief for seniors who need to temporarily halt their Social Security and restart them later.  

If your client has reached the age at which they’re entitled to 100% of the benefit calculated from their lifetime earnings but are not yet age 70, it's possible for them to suspend their retirement benefits. This is one of the cases where they might consider suspending their Social Security – that is, if they chose to receive their Social Security before they reached their Full Retirement Age.  

The Full Retirement Age can vary; anyone born in 1956 will have their Full Retirement Age at 66 and 4 months, which gradually rises to 67 for those born in 1960 and later. 

But why would your client want to stop Social Security? When would such a move be advisable? In this article, InvestmentNews discusses the motivation behind suspended Social Security benefits and other important questions.  

Introduction to Social Security benefit suspension 

Senior citizen clients often rely mainly on their Social Security benefits for their income in their golden years. So, why would a client want their Social Security benefits suspended if they’re so important?  

The main reason why your client chose to suspend their benefits is because they redeemed their Social Security before reaching their Full Retirement Age (FRA). Some retirees sign up for their Social Security when they first become eligible at age 62, simply because they have no other sources of income.  

While this practice can help them with their living expenses, this can significantly reduce their benefit payments when they fully retire. Worse, doing this can make your client lose out on a much bigger monthly paycheck if they didn’t delay their retirement to age 70 instead. These are among the reasons why your client may decide to suspend then restart their cash benefits.  

Common reasons for benefits suspension 

Here are other common reasons why seniors may choose to suspend their Social Security, then restart them later:  

  • They retired when the economy was not ideal. Then, after economic conditions improved, they decided to work longer to save more for retirement.  
  • They took on early retirement options from their employer, but realized they’d like to continue working – even at another employer – so they can put away more money for retirement.  
  • Their income has increased substantially, or they received an inheritance or other financial windfall that makes Social Security benefits unnecessary.  
  • They realized that they could afford to pay for their expenses without Social Security and would rather delay accepting Social Security until age 70. This ensures that they get a bigger monthly check.  

Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) suspension 

If your client is approaching their golden years and has a disability, they can be eligible for both the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) and Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI). 

In case your client has a disability and gets Social Security Disability Insurance, here are instances when these can be suspended:  

Able to return to work 

If the SSDI recipient can return to work and earns more than a specific monthly amount, this can result in a suspension of benefits. However, the SSA offers a trial work period (TWP) for SSDI recipients. The TWP arrangement allows them to work for up to a maximum of 9 months within a rolling 5-year period; this setup does not affect their benefit payments. 

Medical improvement 

If an SSDI beneficiary’s condition improves and they can work, the SSA may suspend disability benefits. The SSA will conduct a Continuing Disability Review (CDR) to determine the degree of their work capability, then recommend a benefits suspension or continuance. 

Reaching Full Retirement Age 

Once an SSDI beneficiary reaches full retirement age, their disability benefits automatically become retirement benefits. Except in this case, the disability benefits shift is not a true benefits suspension; SSI benefits can still be paid alongside retirement benefits. 

Conviction and imprisonment 

These are other serious reasons for SSDI benefits suspension. If an SSDI beneficiary is sentenced for over 30 consecutive days, their benefits are suspended throughout their sentence. Meanwhile, SSI benefits are deemed fully terminated if a beneficiary is incarcerated for 12 consecutive months or longer. 

Committing fraud 

This is another reason for having an SSDI beneficiary’s benefits suspended. If found providing false information or concealing financial income to the SSA, your client can have their benefits suspended.  

Suspension vs termination 

There is a huge difference between having Social Security, whether it’s SSI or SSDI, terminated or suspended. A suspension of benefits can be temporary and removed if a beneficiary meets certain conditions, such as a decrease in earnings below the SGA limit or a change in medical condition. 

On the other hand, the termination of benefits is permanent. This occurs when the beneficiary no longer meets the disability criteria under SSA’s rules, for instance.  

Getting notice of suspension of benefits 

If the SSA decides to suspend benefits, they must inform the beneficiaries in writing.  

The SSA must tell your client in writing before it reduces or stops their benefits. In their notice, which can be a letter or email to your client, the SSA must mention: 

  • why they are suspending or reducing their benefits 
  • when they will impose the suspension, reduction, or termination of benefits 
  • what your client can do if they do not agree with the suspension, reduction, or termination of benefits 

Should your client receive notice, they should contact the SSA. Be warned: It is rare and unusual for SSA employees to directly contact beneficiaries or approach them personally to inform them of their benefits suspension.  

If an SSA notice doesn't appear official, looks suspicious, or your client is personally contacted by someone claiming to work for the SSA, do not give them any information or money. This is likely to be a social security scam and they are best ignored. If this happens, your client should verify with the SSA whether the notice is authentic. 

Options for stopping and restarting Social Security benefits 

Should your client decide to halt their Social Security benefits temporarily and then have them resume later, they have a couple of options: 

1. Withdrawal option 

Withdrawing or canceling Social Security benefits is only possible in the first 12 months of becoming eligible for these benefits. This means this is a once-in-a-lifetime option and is only available once the beneficiary reaches their Full Retirement Age. Should your client decide to do this, they must contact the SSA and fill out Form 521

The beneficiary must repay in full whatever amount they received before the withdrawal or cancellation of benefits. You could say that this process is a Social Security “reset” or “do-over”. 

Dependents of Social Security beneficiaries who choose this option will also have their benefits cancelled. However, the Social Security benefits of their divorced spouses will continue despite this cancellation. 

For a better idea of what your client will owe the SSA pre-cancellation, calculate how much they received in benefits. Don’t forget to include benefits paid to their children or ex-spouse and withholdings for Medicare premiums.  

When to use this option 

Withdrawing or cancelling Social Security benefits can be a good option if a new source of income or work arises soon after your client retires, especially if they took their benefits well before retirement age.  

And the next time they apply for Social Security, they’ll be older and get a higher monthly payment, helping them maximize their Social Security income in their less productive years.  

2. Suspending benefits option 

The option to suspend Social Security benefits is possible once your client reaches Full Retirement Age. What this means is your client stops their benefits and no longer receives monthly payments until they restart or reinstate them. But unlike the withdrawal or cancellation option, there are no back benefits to repay, and this can be done even if your client has already been retired for many years.  

When to use this option 

The major advantage of using this option is that your client earns delayed retirement credits. Pausing Social Security can give significant benefits increases when your client reinstates them. The best scenario for using this option is if the retiree has found a way to earn income in retirement.  

On the topic of delayed retirement credits, here’s a video that describes its benefits in more detail. The presenters also discuss how to know if delaying or suspending Social Security is the right move.  

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-z1o9m3eRK0

Remember, however, the SSA will automatically reinstate their Social Security in the month they turn 70 if they don’t apply for the reinstatement process themselves. But from then on, each monthly payment will be higher than the payments your client received before they suspended their benefits. 

As opposed to the cancellation or withdrawal of benefits, your client’s family members won't have to pay anything back, as no benefits were taken. The caveat is that they likewise won't receive benefits until these are reinstated. However, the exception is again made for divorced spouses, who can still get benefits. 

How to restart Social Security benefits 

When your client decides to reinstate their Social Security benefits, they can either email, call, or make a personal appearance at a local SSA office and state their intention to do so. Here are some important items your client should know about the benefits reinstatement process at the SSA:  

Restarting Social Security after self-suspension or withdrawal 

  • They do not have to sign their request to restart benefit payments. They can make the request orally or in writing, such as via an email or formal letter. 
  • If your client does not make a formal reinstatement request, they can wait until their benefits are automatically reinstated in the month they turn 70. 
  • If your client changes their mind and wants the payments to start before the age of 70, they should inform the SSA when they want their benefits reinstated. 

Reinstating Social Security benefits after incarceration 

Any individual convicted and imprisoned will have their Social Security, whether it’s their benefits from a deceased family member, Disability, or Retirement benefits, suspended. These can only be reinstated after:  

  • the prison made a pre-release agreement with the SSA, and the convict or the prison's representative contacted Social Security at least 90 days before their scheduled release date 
  • the convict informs the SSA of their release; the convict should wait for an SSA representative to contact them with further instructions 
  • if the prison did not have a pre-release agreement with Social Security, the convict can contact the SSA and schedule an appointment to apply for benefits. The convict must have their official prison release documents when they make their appointment 
  • in case the correctional institution releases the convict after the court reverses all charges of the conviction, the court must also agree not to prosecute the freed individual for the same charges 
  • If the court retries them on the same charges, the person must be judged innocent after their new trial 

The effects of suspended or withdrawn Social Security on Medicare 

Your client’s Medicare typically does not change from suspending or withdrawing their Social Security. However, it’s important to remember that Medicare premiums are deducted from their monthly Social Security check.  

You may have to assist your client in computing how much their Medicare premiums will cost them after they suspend or withdraw their Social Security benefits. After all, they’ll have to pay for the premiums out of their own pocket from now on. 

Should your client cite a return to work as their reason for withdrawing benefits, advise them to evaluate and consider their employer-provided healthcare options. As this can vary in coverage and monthly costs, they should compare these plans with the benefits and premiums Medicare offers. They should go with the option that best fits their specific health needs. 

Depending on the circumstances, it can be a simple or complex process for your client to suspend or withdraw their Social Security then reinstate them after a time. After considering factors like the size of their retirement nest egg, their health and longevity, they should also account for paying for their Medicare premiums before they decide to suspend or cancel their benefits.  

As their financial adviser, you can help them weigh their options and suggest the most fitting strategy that will give them the most favourable outcome.  

Don’t forget, you can always look up the opinions of experts in our retirement section here on InvestmentNews.  

Latest News

LPL Financial beats expected earnings helped by record $26B recruitment assets
LPL Financial beats expected earnings helped by record $26B recruitment assets

The firm reported record advisor count, strong organic growth.

Why retaining HNW clients ultimately comes down to one basic thing
Why retaining HNW clients ultimately comes down to one basic thing

New survey finds varied levels of loyalty to advisors by generation.

Stocks drop as investors digest Microsoft, Meta earnings
Stocks drop as investors digest Microsoft, Meta earnings

Busy day for results, key data give markets concerns.

Bryant Riley loan collateral misreported in company filings
Bryant Riley loan collateral misreported in company filings

Incorrect data may have impacted decisions of short-sellers.

Meta will continue to invest millions in AI, metaverse
Meta will continue to invest millions in AI, metaverse

Zuckerberg warns investors to expect more losses.

SPONSORED Out with the old and in with the new: a 50% private markets portfolio

A great man died recently, but this did not make headlines. In fact, it barely even made the news. Maybe it’s because many have already mourned the departure of his greatest legacy: the 60/40 portfolio.

SPONSORED Destiny Wealth Partners: RIA Team of the Year shares keys to success

Discover the award-winning strategies behind Destiny Wealth Partners' client-centric approach.